Patented heated gutter protection from Naperville, IL
Monday to Thursday, 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM; Friday, 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM CST (800) 797-5880

Compared

Heater Cap vs heat tape.

Both are meant to stop ice building up at the roof edge. They are not the same kind of thing, and the difference starts with fire.

What is the difference between Heater Cap and heat tape?

Heat tape is a bare heating wire, usually bought at a hardware store and fitted by the homeowner, which melts a narrow channel through the ice. Heater Cap is a self regulating insulated cable under heat dispersing panels, on its own protected circuit, which clears the whole edge.

Store-bought heat tape
  • Heat tape can spark and cause fires. Many of these products are not temperature regulated. They sit against asphalt shingles, which are an oil derivative and flammable, and against the wood the roof is built from. The insulation covering some of them is thin and easily nicked, which raises the risk further.
  • Constant wattage wire never stops heating.
  • It melts only a thin channel.
  • Nothing protects it from animals.
  • The zigzag is visible all year.
  • It is a do-it-yourself install.
HEATER CAP
  • Self regulating cable that only gets warm.
  • Panels melt whole swathes, not a channel.
  • Valleys, down spouts and drain tiles too.
  • Treat the problem areas only.
  • On its own protected circuit.
  • It fits over most existing gutter covers.
  • It stays out of sight.

The market

Three kinds of heated gutter system.

Heat tape is the first of three, and the differences between them are what decide whether a heated gutter actually keeps up with the snow coming off the roof.

  1. Heat wires

    Bought at a hardware store, mounted on the roof in a zigzag and plugged in. Some have no temperature control at all. The insulation wears, erodes or burns off, which leaves bare wire against a flammable part of the house, and even when they are working properly they only melt a tunnel around the wire.

    The oldest home in Naperville, IL burned down in the winter of 2006. The thin wire system caught the roof on fire.

    From the Homeowner's Guide to Heated Gutter Systems.
  2. Wired panels

    Self regulating cable mounted on the underside of gutter protection. The cable does not get as hot as heat wire, so these are safe, and it is hidden, so the look of the house is not compromised. They are expensive, because of the materials and the licensed electrician, and they still melt only a small area.

  3. Heat-dispersing panel systems, which is what Heater Cap is

    The panel spreads the heat over a wider area, so the system keeps up with the ice and snow accumulating in the gutters and down spouts rather than cutting a line through it. The cables stay hidden, down spouts, roof valleys and drain tiles are treated too, and the whole thing is hardwired and safe. They cost more to install, because a licensed electrician is part of the job, but they work.

This is the client's own framing, set out at length in the free Homeowner's Guide to Heated Gutter Systems.

Dimension by dimension

The whole comparison in one table.

What is compared Store-bought heat tape Heater Cap
Fire risk Many products are not temperature regulated, so nothing stops them getting hotter than they need to be. They sit against asphalt shingles, which are an oil derivative and flammable, and the insulation on some of them is thin and nicks easily. The cable is self regulating and heavily insulated, so it gets warm enough to melt ice and snow and no warmer. It is properly grounded, so it does not spark.
What it clears A thin channel around the wire. The rest of the ice stays where it is, sometimes leaving ice tunnels behind. Whole swathes of snow and ice, because a heat dispersing panel spreads the cable's heat across a far wider area than a bare wire reaches.
Roof valleys Not addressed. A valley is where two or more roof sections meet, and it funnels everything above it into one path. Cable and panels are doubled up in the valleys, because a single run there would be overwhelmed.
Gutters and down spouts A wire laid along the roof edge. Runs along the gutters, down the spouts and into drain tiles where there are any. In some cases it can be applied to underground draining systems.
Animals Nothing protects the wire. Squirrels and whatever else is on the roof chew it. The cable runs under the heat dispersing panel rather than bare across the roof.
How much of the house Whatever length of wire was bought, laid along the roof edge. As much or as little as the house needs. Problem areas can be treated on their own, such as the roof above an entryway, which keeps the energy cost down.
How it looks Permanently mounted and visible all year, zigzagging across the roof. Low profile along the gutter line, in 12 metallic or 9 roof granule finishes, so the house keeps its curb appeal. It installs over most existing aluminum dome gutter cover systems.
Electrical connection Plugged into an outlet. Hardwired onto its own separate circuit, on a 20 or 30 amp GFI breaker with EPD protection, or, for jobs under 100 feet, plugged into a dedicated GFI outlet.
Who installs it Bought at a hardware store and usually fitted by the homeowner. A contractor fits the panels and the cable. On a hardwired job a licensed electrician wires it in and checks it runs without popping the breaker.
Warranty Whatever the manufacturer of the tape offers, on a product the homeowner fitted themselves. A lifetime material warranty on the panel for the original purchaser, and five years on the self regulating heat cable. Splicing the cable voids it and weakens the weather barrier.
A snow covered brick eave with the gutter clear and the down spout running free. A close up of a snow covered roof edge with the Heater Cap panel running along the gutter line below it. Snow lying either side of a roof valley, with the valley itself melted clear down to the gutter.

Is heat tape safe?

Heat tape can spark and cause fires, which is the main reason not to use it.

Many of these products are not temperature regulated, so there is nothing stopping them getting hotter than they need to be. Constant wattage wire keeps putting out the same heat whatever the weather is doing, and it can arc or spark where it touches metal. They are mounted against asphalt shingles, and the asphalt in a shingle is an oil derivative and therefore flammable, as is any wood the wire touches. The insulation on some of them is thin and nicks easily, or wears and burns off, which leaves bare wire against the roof.

Heater Cap's cable is self regulating and heavily insulated, so it only ever gets warm enough to melt ice and snow, and it is properly grounded to avoid sparking.

Does heat tape actually clear the ice?

Only a thin channel of it. A bare wire does not spread heat properly, so it melts poorly: the area immediately around it goes and the rest of the ice stays where it is, sometimes leaving ice tunnels behind. The ice problem is therefore still there, just with a groove cut through it. Heater Cap's panels disperse the heat over a much wider area, so whole swathes of snow and ice come off the roof and gutters, and the down spouts, the roof valleys and the drain tiles are treated too.

How do the two look on a house?

Heat tape is permanently mounted and visible all year, zigzagging across the roof, which takes away from the look of the home. The effect is rather like the neighbor who leaves the Christmas lights up through the summer. A bare wire up there is also unprotected from squirrels and other animals. Heater Cap keeps the curb appeal of the house: the cable runs under a panel that comes in 12 metallic and 9 roof granule finishes, it installs over most existing aluminum dome gutter cover systems, and it is virtually invisible from the ground.

Who installs each one?

Heat tape is usually fitted by the homeowner. Heater Cap is fitted by a contractor, and on a hardwired job a licensed electrician wires it in. There is a good reason licensed electricians exist: electricity is dangerous. Heater Cap goes onto its own separate circuit with a 20 or 30 amp GFI breaker carrying EPD protection, and the electrician checks the system runs without tripping it. Jobs under 100 feet can be plugged into a dedicated GFI outlet instead, and then the contractor finishes the work on their own.

And the warranty?

Heat tape carries whatever its manufacturer offers on a product the homeowner fitted themselves. Heater Cap carries a lifetime material warranty on the panel for the original purchaser and five years on the self regulating heat cable, and it is made in the USA.

Get ahead of the first freeze.

Installers book up fast once the snow starts. Reach out now.